How to read this player page

The big number is this season's NUT, his total production against league average, with its letter grade. Below that are his season and career lines, recent form over 7, 14 and 30 days, game logs, and percentile ranks against every qualified player. NUT is built on the advanced hitting and pitching stats analysts trust, with defense left out, so the number reflects what the player controls.

Jim O'Toole 2026 Season · CWS

Career: 98-84, 3.57 ERA, 1039 K in 1615.1 IP.

NUT leaderboard · What is NUT?

Jim O'Toole Stats & Profile | Baseball NUT

Jim O'Toole

#31

P · CWS

Compare

AGreat

+8.4Career NUT

+9.6 to Nutty

Career

3.57ERA1.29WHIP98W1039K1615.1IP4SV

S/L · 6' 0", 195 lb · b. Jan 10, 1937 · Chicago, IL · Signed Undrafted FA, 1958

Player Overview

Year by Year


1958	21	CIN	—	0	1	1.29	1	1	0	0	0	0	31	7.0	4	1	5	0	4	1.29
1959	22	CIN	-1.2	5	8	5.15	28	19	3	1	4	0	592	129.1	144	74	73	4	68	1.68
1960	23	CIN	+1.3	12	12	3.80	34	31	7	2	1	1	834	196.1	198	83	66	4	124	1.34
1961	24	CIN	+2.6	19	9	3.10	39	35	11	3	2	2	1061	252.2	229	87	93	3	178	1.27
1962	25	CIN	+1.6	16	13	3.50	36	34	11	3	1	0	1039	251.2	222	98	87	5	170	1.23
1963	26	CIN	+2.1	17	14	2.88	33	32	12	5	0	0	955	234.1	208	75	57	3	146	1.13
1964	27	CIN	+3.0	17	7	2.66	30	30	9	3	0	0	888	220.0	194	65	51	0	145	1.11
1965	28	CIN	-0.8	3	10	5.92	29	22	2	0	2	1	585	127.2	154	84	47	3	71	1.57
1966	29	CIN	-0.4	5	7	3.55	25	24	2	0	1	0	606	142.0	139	56	49	3	96	1.32
1967	30	CWS	+0.1	4	3	2.82	15	10	1	1	1	0	233	54.1	53	17	18	1	37	1.31
Career	—	10 yrs	+8.4	98	84	3.57	270	238	58	18	12	4	6824	1615.1	1545	640	546	26	1039	1.29

Stat definitions →

NUT Breakdown

K Ability

HR Prevention

Walk Avoidance

What's driving O'Toole's career NUT of +8.4

Slice size = share of total NUT. K Ability = Strikeouts · HR Prevention = HR allowed · Walk Avoidance = BB + HBP.

Career NUT Trend

596061626364656667

NUT by Season

-1.2

+1.3

+2.6

+1.6

+2.1

+3.0

-0.8

-0.4

+0.1

Awards

1961NL Player of the Month

1963NL All-Star

The week in MLB, ranked by NUT. Free, every Monday.

The week’s top performers by NUT and the games you missed.

Free · At most 1 email a week · Unsubscribe anytimeSee last week’s report→