How to read this player page

The big number is this season's NUT, his total production against league average, with its letter grade. Below that are his season and career lines, recent form over 7, 14 and 30 days, game logs, and percentile ranks against every qualified player. NUT is built on the advanced hitting and pitching stats analysts trust, with defense left out, so the number reflects what the player controls.

Carl Mays 2026 Season · SF

Career: 208-126, 2.92 ERA, 862 K in 3021.1 IP.

NUT leaderboard · What is NUT?

Carl Mays Career Stats & NUT | Baseball NUT

Carl Mays

P · SF

Compare

BGood

+6.7Career NUT

+1.3 to Great

Career

2.92ERA1.21WHIP208W862K3021.1IP31SV

L/R · 6' 0", 195 lb · b. Nov 12, 1891 · Liberty, KY · Signed Undrafted FA, 1915

Player Overview

Year by Year


1915	23	BOS	+1.5	6	5	2.60	38	6	2	0	27	7	514	131.2	119	38	21	5	65	1.06
1916	24	BOS	-0.5	18	13	2.39	44	24	14	2	13	3	972	245.0	208	65	74	9	76	1.15
1917	25	BOS	+0.4	22	9	1.74	35	33	27	2	2	0	1129	289.0	230	56	74	14	91	1.05
1918	26	BOS	+1.1	21	13	2.21	35	33	30	8	1	0	1162	293.1	230	72	81	11	114	1.06
1919	27	BOS	+0.2	5	11	2.47	21	16	14	2	4	2	576	146.0	131	40	40	5	53	1.17
1919	27	NYY	+0.3	9	3	1.65	13	13	12	1	0	0	487	120.0	96	22	37	5	54	1.11
1919	27	TOT	+0.5	14	14	2.10	34	29	26	3	4	2	1063	266.0	227	62	77	10	107	1.14
1920	28	NYY	-0.5	26	11	3.06	45	37	26	6	8	2	1268	312.0	310	106	84	7	92	1.26
1921	29	NYY	+0.3	27	9	3.05	49	38	30	1	10	7	1400	336.2	332	114	76	9	70	1.21
1922	30	NYY	-0.1	13	14	3.60	34	29	21	1	4	2	988	240.0	257	96	50	7	41	1.28
1923	31	NYY	-1.0	5	2	6.20	23	7	2	0	11	0	383	81.1	119	56	32	4	16	1.86
1924	32	CIN	+1.9	20	9	3.15	37	27	15	2	10	0	940	226.0	238	79	36	4	63	1.21
1925	33	CIN	+0.4	3	5	3.31	12	5	3	0	5	2	225	51.2	60	19	13	2	10	1.41
1926	34	CIN	+2.1	19	12	3.14	39	33	24	3	2	1	1158	281.0	286	98	53	4	58	1.21
1927	35	CIN	+0.7	3	7	3.51	14	9	6	0	4	0	343	82.0	89	32	10	1	17	1.21
1928	36	CIN	-0.2	4	1	3.88	14	6	4	1	4	1	269	62.2	67	27	22	0	10	1.42
1929	37	NYG	+0.2	7	2	4.32	37	8	1	0	19	4	538	123.0	140	59	31	2	32	1.39
Career	—	15 yrs	+6.7	208	126	2.92	490	324	231	29	124	31	12352	3021.1	2912	979	734	89	862	1.21

Stat definitions →

NUT Breakdown

K Ability

HR Prevention

Walk Avoidance

What's driving Mays's career NUT of +6.7

Slice size = share of total NUT. K Ability = Strikeouts · HR Prevention = HR allowed · Walk Avoidance = BB + HBP.

Career NUT Trend

2.1

151617181920212223242526272829

NUT by Season

+1.5

-0.5

+0.4

+1.1

+0.5

-0.5

+0.3

-0.1

-1.0

+1.9

+0.4

+2.1

+0.7

-0.2

+0.2

Awards

1916World Series Championship

1918World Series Championship

The week in MLB, ranked by NUT. Free, every Monday.

The week’s top performers by NUT and the games you missed.

Free · At most 1 email a week · Unsubscribe anytimeSee last week’s report→