How to read this player page

The big number is this season's NUT, his total production against league average, with its letter grade. Below that are his season and career lines, recent form over 7, 14 and 30 days, game logs, and percentile ranks against every qualified player. NUT is built on the advanced hitting and pitching stats analysts trust, with defense left out, so the number reflects what the player controls.

Max Butcher 2026 Season · PIT

Career: 95-106, 3.74 ERA, 485 K in 1786.1 IP.

NUT leaderboard · What is NUT?

Max Butcher Stats & Profile | Baseball NUT

Max Butcher

#19

P · PIT

Compare

FBad

-2.1Career NUT

+0.1 to Weak

Career

3.74ERA1.41WHIP95W485K1786.1IP9SV

R/R · 6' 2", 220 lb · b. Sep 21, 1910 · Holden, WV · Signed Undrafted FA, 1936

Player Overview

Year by Year


1936	25	BRO	-0.3	6	6	3.96	38	15	5	0	10	2	643	147.2	154	65	59	1	55	1.44
1937	26	BRO	-0.7	11	15	4.27	39	24	8	1	11	0	823	191.2	203	91	75	7	57	1.45
1938	27	BRO	-1.1	5	4	6.56	24	8	3	0	8	2	355	72.2	104	53	39	1	21	1.97
1938	27	PHI	+0.0	4	8	2.93	12	12	11	0	0	0	414	98.1	94	32	31	2	29	1.27
1938	27	TOT	-1.0	9	12	4.47	36	20	14	0	8	2	769	171.0	198	85	70	3	50	1.57
1939	28	PHI	-1.1	2	13	5.61	19	16	3	0	3	0	491	104.1	131	65	51	1	27	1.74
1939	28	PIT	+0.6	4	4	3.43	14	12	5	2	0	0	382	86.2	104	33	23	0	21	1.47
1939	28	TOT	-0.6	6	17	4.62	33	28	8	2	3	0	873	191.0	235	98	74	1	48	1.62
1940	29	PIT	-0.7	8	9	6.01	35	24	6	2	5	2	608	136.1	161	91	46	1	40	1.52
1941	30	PIT	+0.5	17	12	3.05	33	32	19	0	1	0	1017	236.0	249	80	66	1	61	1.33
1942	31	PIT	+0.2	5	8	2.93	24	18	9	0	4	1	642	150.2	144	49	44	2	49	1.25
1943	32	PIT	+0.3	10	8	2.65	33	21	10	2	9	1	804	193.2	191	57	57	2	45	1.28
1944	33	PIT	+0.2	13	11	3.12	35	27	13	5	6	1	854	199.0	216	69	46	1	43	1.32
1945	34	PIT	-0.1	10	8	3.03	28	20	12	2	3	0	728	169.1	184	57	46	4	37	1.36
Career	—	10 yrs	-2.1	95	106	3.74	334	229	104	14	60	9	7761	1786.1	1935	742	583	23	485	1.41

Stat definitions →

NUT Breakdown

K Ability

HR Prevention

Walk Avoidance

What's driving Butcher's career NUT of -2.1

Slice size = share of total NUT. K Ability = Strikeouts · HR Prevention = HR allowed · Walk Avoidance = BB + HBP.

Career NUT Trend

0.5

36373839404142434445

NUT by Season

-0.3

-0.7

-1.0

-0.6

-0.7

+0.5

+0.2

+0.3

+0.2

-0.1

The week in MLB, ranked by NUT. Free, every Monday.

The week’s top performers by NUT and the games you missed.

Free · At most 1 email a week · Unsubscribe anytimeSee last week’s report→