Juan Soto leads in 2026 with +2.3 season NUT to Judge’s +1.1, a 1.2-point edge. Over their careers, Judge leads in career NUT, +43.9 to +34.3, in 5,278 plate appearances to Soto’s 5,282. Judge has 3 MVP awards; Soto has no MVP awards.
NUT — Net Unbiased Total. One number for a player’s production, measured against league average for that season, so any era compares on the same scale. Zero is average; higher is better. Hitters and pitchers are graded on separate scales. Learn more →
Awards
Aaron Judge
3× MVP(2022, 2024, 2025) · Rookie of the Year(2017)
Juan Soto
No MVP, Cy Young, or Rookie of the Year awards on record
Both players' season and career stats, side by side, with NUT first. The better number in each row is highlighted. Career NUT adds up each season against that year's league average, so players from different eras compare fairly. Build any other matchup with the Stat Comparison tool.
.275
OBP
.360
.393
SLG
.511
.515
HR
18
27
RBI
41
68
SB
5
9
.281
OBP
.410
.415
SLG
.610
.530
HR
386
271
RBI
871
765
SB
70
104
Where they rank among 2026 hitters
Each player's place on the full 2026 NUT board for qualified hitters, with the players ranked around him.