Underrated MLB Free Agents 2026-27: Pederson, Newcomb by NUT
The most underrated free agents of 2026 by NUT are Joc Pederson (+1.3 SEASON NUT, B), the top hitter outside MLB.com's top 30 free agents, and Sean Newcomb (+1.0, B), the top pitcher outside it, as of November 17, 2026. Pederson finished ahead of 6 of the 10 unsigned hitters on that list with 2026 MLB stats, and Newcomb ahead of 11 of its 17 pitchers. The headline names, Randy Arozarena and Tarik Skubal among them, are ranked in the top MLB free agents by NUT.
The pool is every player who filed for free agency after the 2026 season, reached the 2026 qualifying bar (150 plate appearances or 50 innings) and had no signing or reported deal through November 17: 60 hitters and 72 pitchers. Jake Bauers (Boston), Dustin May (White Sox), Tim Hill (Yankees), Emilio Pagán (Detroit) and Evan Phillips (Atlanta) are out. Hitters and pitchers grade on separate scales, so each board stays within one role.
MLB.com's 5 Under-the-Radar Free Agents, by NUT
On November 17, MLB.com had five writers and researchers each pick one unsigned free agent from outside Mark Feinsand's top 30 list: Kris Bubic, Tyler Stephenson, Taylor Ward, Hiromi Itoh and Alex Vesia. Their cases lean on track record, health and pitch data. Here is what each one produced in 2026:
Alex Vesia is the only one of the five in the top 12 of his role: 74 strikeouts in 58 innings for the Dodgers, +0.7 (B). Kris Bubic's +0.4 came in 55 innings across Kansas City and Los Angeles, just over the 50-inning bar.
Taylor Ward reached base at a .359 clip for Baltimore and Seattle but hit 7 home runs in 607 plate appearances, and finished at -0.2 (C). Tyler Stephenson's +0.1 counts only his bat; NUT leaves out defense, including a catcher's blocking and framing. Hiromi Itoh, posted by Nippon-Ham, has no major league line yet, so he has no NUT.
Underrated Free-Agent Hitters by NUT
Joc Pederson hit 26 home runs in 431 plate appearances for Texas, and his +1.3 ranks 5th among all 60 unsigned free-agent hitters. Four hitters on MLB.com's top 30 finished ahead of him: Arozarena (+3.4), Seiya Suzuki (+2.6), Ty France (+2.3) and Brandon Lowe (+2.1). Six finished behind him, from Ryan Jeffers (+1.2) and Luis Arraez (+0.6) down to Alec Bohm (-0.4).
Randal Grichuk posted an .880 OPS, the highest of any free-agent hitter in the pool, in 280 plate appearances split between the Yankees and White Sox. Gary Sánchez reached base at a .349 clip for the champion Brewers, and he is the top free-agent catcher outside the top 30.
Underrated Free-Agent Pitchers by NUT
All eight pitched mostly in relief. Sean Newcomb threw 90.1 innings for the White Sox, 6 of them starts, and Jonathan Loáisiga walked 13 batters in 67 innings for Arizona. Both finished ahead of 11 of the 17 pitchers on MLB.com's top 30 with 2026 stats, among them Kevin Gausman (+0.9), Raisel Iglesias (+0.7), Michael King (+0.1) and Freddy Peralta (-0.2).
Seven of the eight throw left-handed. Steven Okert posted a 2.13 ERA over 67.2 innings for Houston, the lowest of the group.
Best Value Starters Outside the Top 30
David Peterson made 23 starts for the Mets and Cubs and finished at +0.4, ahead of six starters on MLB.com's top 30: Tyler Mahle (+0.3), Michael King (+0.1), Casey Mize (+0.1), Freddy Peralta (-0.2), Shota Imanaga (-0.6) and Robbie Ray (-1.0). His 4.79 ERA is higher than all six of theirs; NUT is not built on ERA.
Why Under-the-Radar Free Agents Can Pay Off
Ty France is last winter's example. He signed a minor league deal with San Diego for 2026, then finished at +2.3 SEASON NUT (B) with a .865 OPS. That ranks 3rd among this winter's unsigned free-agent hitters, and he is No. 27 on MLB.com's top 30 this time.
In all, 14 unsigned free agents outside the top 30 finished 2026 at +0.5 or better: 5 hitters and 9 pitchers. 12 of the 27 unsigned players on MLB.com's top 30 with 2026 MLB stats finished below it.
NUT is one number for production against league average, built on the advanced hitting and pitching stats analysts trust, not batting average or ERA. Defense is left out. It measures what a player did in 2026, not his age, health, stuff or contract, which is where scouting lists like MLB.com's look instead. Every value here is SEASON NUT, graded S, A, B, C, D or F on the hitter or pitcher scale the app uses for a full season.
Where each club's weakest spot is, and which free agent fits it: MLB team needs by NUT. These players have until the December 1 labor deadline to sign before a possible freeze: MLB lockout 2026 explained.
MLB’s winter moves, ranked by production. Free, once a month.
Signings, trades and the season’s best by NUT. Next: Mon, Dec 7.
Quick Answers
Who is the most underrated MLB free agent in 2026?
By 2026 SEASON NUT, Joc Pederson tops the hitters outside MLB.com's top 30 at +1.3 (B), with 26 home runs in 431 plate appearances for Texas. Sean Newcomb tops the pitchers at +1.0 (B).
How do MLB.com's under-the-radar free agents rate by NUT?
Alex Vesia rates highest at +0.7 SEASON NUT (B), 12th of 72 unsigned free-agent pitchers. Kris Bubic is at +0.4, Tyler Stephenson +0.1 and Taylor Ward -0.2; Hiromi Itoh has no MLB stats yet.
Which free-agent relievers are underrated?
Sean Newcomb (+1.0), Jonathan Loáisiga (+1.0) and Tyler Alexander (+0.9) each finished 2026 ahead of 11 of the 17 pitchers on MLB.com's top 30 who have 2026 MLB stats.
Was Ty France underrated last winter?
Yes, by NUT. He signed a minor league deal with San Diego for 2026 and finished at +2.3 SEASON NUT with a .865 OPS, 3rd among this winter's 60 unsigned free-agent hitters.