2027 Hall of Fame Ballot by NUT: A-Rod, Pettitte, Posey Ranked
Who Is on the 2027 Hall of Fame Ballot?
Alex Rodriguez has the highest career NUT on the 2027 Hall of Fame ballot, at +67.9, 20th among 7,896 hitters since 1876. Andy Pettitte leads the pitchers at +24.0, and first-time candidate Buster Posey is at +20.1. Values are as of November 17, 2026.
The BBWAA released the official ballot on November 16, 2026: 27 players, 14 of them first-time candidates and 13 returning players who each got at least 5% of the vote in 2026. Voting closes December 31, results are announced January 19, 2027, and a player needs 75% of the vote to be elected.
NUT is one number for production against league average, built on the advanced hitting and pitching stats analysts trust, not batting average or ERA. Career NUT adds up every season, each graded against its own league. NUT leaves out defense, so a catcher like Posey and glove-first players like Omar Vizquel and Jimmy Rollins are measured only on what they did at the plate.
2027 Hall of Fame Ballot Hitters Ranked by Career NUT
Career NUT and grade, main club and position, 2026 vote share and year on the ballot for returning players, best season, and rank among all hitters since 1876.
David Wright is #3 among ballot hitters by career NUT and got 14.8% of the vote in 2026, 7th of the 8 returning hitters. Bobby Abreu is #2 by NUT at 30.8%. Rodriguez’s vote has been held down by his 2014 season-long suspension under MLB’s drug policy. Chase Utley, the vote leader at 59.1%, is #4 by NUT.
2027 Hall of Fame Ballot Pitchers Ranked by Career NUT
Pitchers are graded on their own career scale. Pettitte, in his 9th year at 48.5%, and Félix Hernández, in his 3rd at 46.1%, are the top two by career NUT and by vote.
Jake Arrieta’s 2015 Cy Young season, at +4.4, is the best single season by any pitcher on the ballot, but his career total of +2.4 ranks 10th of 11.
How the Candidates Compare With Recent Hall of Famers
The writers elected 8 players from 2024 to 2026. Their career NUT is the bar the 2027 class is measured against.
Seven hitters on the 2027 ballot have more career NUT than 2026 inductee Andruw Jones (+15.6): Rodriguez, Abreu, David Wright, Utley, Posey, Dustin Pedroia and Ryan Zimmerman. Pettitte and Hernández are both above CC Sabathia (+18.2). Much of Jones’s case was his defense in center field, which NUT does not count.
Buster Posey and Jon Lester, the First-Time Headliners
Posey’s +20.1 career NUT is the highest of the new hitters, ahead of Zimmerman (+17.3). His best season was his 2012 NL MVP year at +4.7, and his career NUT is 4.6 below Joe Mauer’s (+24.7), the last catcher the writers elected. His full case against all 17 Hall of Fame catchers is in Buster Posey’s Hall of Fame case by NUT. Lester leads the new pitchers at +11.7, 2.8 ahead of reliever Joakim Soria (+8.9).
See every career on the all-time boards, the best players who never won an MVP in the best players to never win MVP by NUT, and the best single years in the best seasons in MLB history. Posey’s 2012 is ranked with every other winner in all 193 MVP winners by NUT.
MLB’s winter moves, ranked by production. Free, once a month.
Signings, trades and the season’s best by NUT. Next: Mon, Dec 7.
Quick Answers
Who is on the 2027 Hall of Fame ballot?
27 players: 14 first-time candidates led by Buster Posey and Jon Lester, and 13 returning players led by Chase Utley (59.1% in 2026). The BBWAA released the ballot on November 16, 2026.
When are the 2027 Hall of Fame results announced?
January 19, 2027. A player needs 75% of the writers’ votes to be elected and 5% to stay on the ballot.
Who has the highest career NUT on the 2027 ballot?
Alex Rodriguez, at +67.9 career NUT, 20th among 7,896 hitters since 1876. Andy Pettitte leads the pitchers at +24.0, 37th among 7,125.
Will Buster Posey make the Hall of Fame?
His +20.1 career NUT ranks 5th among hitters on the ballot and is above 2026 inductee Andruw Jones (+15.6). NUT leaves out defense, where a catcher adds much of his value.
Is this Omar Vizquel’s last year on the ballot?
Yes. 2027 is his 10th year, the limit. He got 18.4% in 2026, and his -24.7 career NUT is the lowest on the ballot.